Table of Contents

40 S&W vs 9mm: Which Caliber Reigns Supreme?

The debate between the .40 Smith & Wesson (S&W) and the 9mm Luger (9x19mm) is one of the most enduring in the firearms world. For decades, shooters have argued over which caliber offers the better balance of power, capacity, and recoil. Are you trying to decide which is best for self-defense, target shooting, or law enforcement? This comprehensive guide cuts through the noise, providing an in-depth, expert-backed comparison to help you make an informed decision.

We will explore the nuances of each cartridge, examining ballistics, recoil, capacity, cost, and real-world performance. This isn’t just about specs on paper; we’ll delve into how these factors translate to practical shooting scenarios. Drawing on insights from experienced shooters, law enforcement professionals, and ballistics experts, this article aims to provide a balanced perspective, empowering you to choose the right caliber for your needs.

Understanding the .40 S&W and 9mm Cartridges

The .40 S&W was developed in the early 1990s as a compromise between the 9mm and the .45 ACP. The FBI sought a cartridge with more stopping power than the 9mm but with higher magazine capacity and less recoil than the .45 ACP. Smith & Wesson and Winchester co-developed the .40 S&W to meet these requirements.

The 9mm, on the other hand, has a much longer history, dating back to the early 1900s. Designed by Georg Luger, it quickly gained popularity worldwide and is now one of the most widely used pistol cartridges. Its popularity stems from its manageable recoil, high capacity, and relatively low cost.

Both cartridges are centerfire, meaning the primer is located in the center of the cartridge base. They are typically loaded with jacketed hollow point (JHP) bullets for self-defense, designed to expand upon impact and deliver more energy to the target. However, they can also be found with full metal jacket (FMJ) bullets for target shooting and practice.

Ballistics and Stopping Power: A Head-to-Head Comparison

One of the key areas of debate is the ballistic performance of the two cartridges. The .40 S&W generally offers a heavier bullet with a larger diameter, which translates to more kinetic energy upon impact. Advocates argue this results in greater stopping power.

However, advancements in 9mm bullet technology have narrowed the gap. Modern 9mm JHPs can achieve impressive expansion and penetration, rivaling the performance of some .40 S&W loads. The effectiveness of a cartridge depends heavily on bullet design and shot placement. As many experts emphasize, a well-placed shot with a 9mm is far more effective than a poorly placed shot with a .40 S&W.

To illustrate, consider typical ballistics data. A common .40 S&W load might fire a 180-grain bullet at around 1,000 feet per second (fps), generating approximately 400 foot-pounds of energy. A standard 9mm load might fire a 124-grain bullet at around 1,150 fps, producing roughly 365 foot-pounds of energy. While the .40 S&W has a slight edge in energy, the difference is not always significant in real-world scenarios.

Penetration and Expansion

Penetration is crucial for reaching vital organs, while expansion increases the size of the wound channel. Both cartridges, when loaded with quality JHP bullets, can meet the FBI’s penetration standards (12-18 inches in ballistic gelatin). However, the .40 S&W typically exhibits slightly more consistent penetration, while some 9mm loads may expand more dramatically.

Recoil and Controllability: The Shooter’s Perspective

Recoil is a significant factor influencing a shooter’s ability to control the firearm and deliver accurate follow-up shots. The .40 S&W generally produces more recoil than the 9mm due to its heavier bullet and higher energy levels. This can make it more challenging to control, especially for less experienced shooters.

The snappier recoil of the .40 S&W can lead to slower recovery times between shots and reduced accuracy, particularly in rapid-fire situations. The 9mm, with its milder recoil, allows for faster and more accurate follow-up shots, which can be critical in self-defense scenarios.

However, recoil is subjective, and individual shooters may perceive it differently. Factors such as grip strength, shooting technique, and the firearm’s design can all influence how recoil is felt. Some shooters may find the .40 S&W manageable with proper training and technique, while others may prefer the more forgiving recoil of the 9mm.

Capacity and Firearm Size: Practical Considerations

Magazine capacity is another important consideration, especially for self-defense. The 9mm typically allows for higher magazine capacities compared to the .40 S&W in similarly sized firearms. This is because the 9mm cartridge is smaller in diameter, allowing more rounds to fit in the magazine.

For example, a Glock 17 (9mm) typically holds 17 rounds in its standard magazine, while a Glock 22 (.40 S&W) holds 15 rounds. This difference of two rounds may seem small, but it can be significant in a high-stress situation where every shot counts. Many newer 9mm handguns have a capacity of 19 or even 24 rounds.

Firearm size and weight are also factors to consider, especially for concealed carry. 9mm pistols tend to be smaller and lighter than .40 S&W pistols, making them more comfortable to carry for extended periods. This can be a significant advantage for individuals who carry concealed regularly.

Cost and Availability: A Matter of Economics

The cost of ammunition is an ongoing consideration for most shooters. Generally, 9mm ammunition is less expensive than .40 S&W ammunition. This is due to the 9mm’s widespread popularity and higher production volumes. The cost difference can be significant over time, especially for frequent shooters who practice regularly.

Availability is also a factor to consider. 9mm ammunition is typically more readily available than .40 S&W ammunition, especially during times of high demand. This can make it easier to find and purchase 9mm ammunition for practice and self-defense.

Reloading is another option for reducing ammunition costs. Both 9mm and .40 S&W cartridges can be reloaded, but the cost savings may be more significant with the 9mm due to the lower cost of components.

Real-World Performance: Law Enforcement and Self-Defense

Both the .40 S&W and 9mm have been widely adopted by law enforcement agencies and civilians for self-defense. The .40 S&W gained popularity in the 1990s and early 2000s, with many law enforcement agencies switching from 9mm to .40 S&W, seeking greater stopping power. However, in recent years, many agencies have switched back to 9mm, citing advancements in bullet technology and the benefits of higher capacity and reduced recoil.

The FBI, for example, switched back to 9mm in 2015 after extensive testing, concluding that modern 9mm ammunition offered comparable performance to the .40 S&W with the added benefits of higher capacity and improved shooter accuracy. This decision has influenced many other law enforcement agencies to follow suit.

In self-defense situations, both cartridges can be effective when used with proper training and shot placement. The key is to choose the cartridge that you can shoot accurately and consistently under stress. Consider that the best gun is the one you have with you and can use effectively.

The Glock 22: A .40 S&W Workhorse

The Glock 22, chambered in .40 S&W, has earned a reputation as a reliable and durable service pistol. Widely adopted by law enforcement agencies, it provides a balance of power and capacity. It’s a polymer-framed, striker-fired pistol known for its simple design and ease of maintenance.

The Glock 22 offers a full-size grip and a 4.49-inch barrel, providing a comfortable shooting experience for many users. Its weight, around 22.04 oz (unloaded), helps to absorb some of the .40 S&W’s recoil. The Glock 22 is often seen as a direct competitor to the Glock 17 (9mm), offering a similar platform with a different caliber.

Key Features of the Glock 22

Polymer Frame: The Glock 22’s polymer frame makes it lightweight and resistant to corrosion. This is a key advantage for law enforcement officers who may be exposed to harsh environments.
Safe Action System: Glock’s Safe Action System is a three-part mechanical safety system that prevents accidental discharge. This provides an added layer of security without compromising the pistol’s ease of use.
Accessory Rail: The Glock 22 features an accessory rail for mounting lights, lasers, and other tactical accessories. This allows users to customize the pistol to their specific needs.
Fixed Sights: The Glock 22 comes standard with fixed sights, which are durable and easy to use. However, aftermarket sights are readily available for those who prefer a different sight picture.
High Capacity Magazine: The Glock 22’s standard magazine holds 15 rounds of .40 S&W ammunition. This provides a good balance of capacity and concealability.
Simple Disassembly: The Glock 22 is easy to disassemble for cleaning and maintenance. This is a key feature for users who want to keep their pistol in top condition.
Durability: Glocks are known for their durability. The Glock 22 can withstand high round counts and continue to function reliably.

Advantages of Choosing the Glock 22 (.40 S&W)

The Glock 22 in .40 S&W offers several key advantages. The .40 S&W cartridge delivers more energy on impact than the 9mm, potentially leading to quicker incapacitation. Its full-size frame provides a comfortable grip and helps to manage recoil, and its simple design and reliability make it a trusted choice for law enforcement and self-defense.

Users frequently report feeling more confident with the .40 S&W’s perceived stopping power. While shot placement remains critical, the added energy of the .40 S&W provides a psychological advantage for some shooters. Moreover, the Glock 22’s proven track record in law enforcement lends credibility to its effectiveness as a defensive weapon.

Our analysis indicates that the Glock 22, when paired with quality JHP ammunition, offers a potent combination of power and reliability. Its manageable recoil (for experienced shooters) and adequate magazine capacity make it a viable option for those prioritizing stopping power.

A Thorough Look at the Glock 22: An Expert Review

The Glock 22 is a well-regarded pistol, but it’s important to consider its strengths and weaknesses to determine if it’s the right choice for you. This review provides an unbiased assessment of the Glock 22, covering its user experience, performance, and overall value.

User Experience & Usability: The Glock 22 is known for its simple design and ease of use. Its polymer frame makes it lightweight and comfortable to hold, while its textured grip provides a secure purchase. The controls are intuitive and easy to operate, even under stress. Disassembly for cleaning is straightforward, requiring no special tools.

Performance & Effectiveness: The Glock 22 delivers reliable performance with a variety of .40 S&W ammunition. Its accuracy is adequate for self-defense distances, and its recoil is manageable with proper technique. The pistol’s durability is legendary, capable of withstanding thousands of rounds without significant wear and tear.

Pros:

Reliability: Glocks are known for their reliability, and the Glock 22 is no exception. It consistently functions without malfunctions, even under adverse conditions.
Durability: The Glock 22 can withstand high round counts and continue to function reliably. Its polymer frame is resistant to corrosion and wear.
Simple Design: The Glock 22’s simple design makes it easy to learn and operate. Its controls are intuitive and easy to use.
Manageable Recoil: While the .40 S&W cartridge has more recoil than the 9mm, the Glock 22’s full-size frame helps to mitigate it.
Proven Track Record: The Glock 22 has a long history of service with law enforcement agencies, demonstrating its effectiveness as a defensive weapon.

Cons/Limitations:

Recoil: The .40 S&W cartridge produces more recoil than the 9mm, which can be challenging for some shooters.
Magazine Capacity: The Glock 22’s magazine capacity (15 rounds) is lower than some 9mm pistols.
Grip Angle: Some users find the Glock’s grip angle to be uncomfortable or unnatural.
Trigger: The Glock trigger can be mushy, although many aftermarket options are available.

Ideal User Profile: The Glock 22 is best suited for experienced shooters who prioritize stopping power and reliability. It’s a good choice for law enforcement officers, security professionals, and individuals who want a dependable self-defense pistol.

Key Alternatives: The Glock 17 (9mm) is a popular alternative to the Glock 22, offering higher capacity and less recoil. The Sig Sauer P320 is another option, known for its modularity and customizable features.

Expert Overall Verdict & Recommendation: The Glock 22 is a solid choice for those seeking a reliable and powerful .40 S&W pistol. Its proven track record and simple design make it a trusted option for self-defense. However, its recoil may be challenging for some shooters, so it’s important to try it before you buy it.

Making the Right Choice for You

Ultimately, the choice between the .40 S&W and the 9mm depends on individual preferences and priorities. The .40 S&W offers a slight edge in stopping power, while the 9mm provides higher capacity, less recoil, and lower cost. Both cartridges can be effective for self-defense when used with proper training and shot placement.

Consider your shooting experience, hand strength, and recoil tolerance. If you are a new shooter or have difficulty controlling recoil, the 9mm may be a better choice. If you prioritize stopping power and are comfortable with more recoil, the .40 S&W may be a better fit.

We encourage you to try shooting both calibers before making a decision. Visit a local gun range and rent firearms chambered in both .40 S&W and 9mm. This will allow you to experience the recoil and handling characteristics of each cartridge firsthand and determine which one you prefer. By carefully considering your needs and preferences, you can choose the right caliber for your self-defense needs.